Why Did Emma Smith Leave the Church?

Emma Smith, the wife of Joseph Smith, remains one of the most complex figures in Latter-day Saint history. She played a pivotal role in the early Church, yet after Joseph’s death, she chose not to follow Brigham Young and the majority of the Saints westward. This decision has led many to ask, why did Emma Smith leave the Church? Some have even wondered, was Emma Smith excommunicated? While she was never formally removed from Church membership, her decision to remain in Nauvoo and her later association with the Reorganized Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (RLDS) have fueled debates about her legacy and standing in Mormon history.

Emma’s Early Contributions to the Church

Before exploring why did Emma Smith leave the LDS Church, it’s important to recognize her deep involvement in the early Restoration. Emma was not merely Joseph Smith’s wife; she was his partner in many critical aspects of the Church’s formation. She was instrumental in the translation of the Book of Mormon, acting as a scribe and providing unwavering support. She also compiled the first hymnal and was designated as an “Elect Lady” in the Doctrine and Covenants, a title that emphasized her spiritual leadership.

Yet, Emma’s relationship with the Church became strained over time. Many issues contributed to this rift, including financial struggles, leadership conflicts, and most notably, Joseph Smith’s practice of plural marriage. The question of Joseph Smith wives was particularly painful for Emma, as she resisted the doctrine of polygamy even as her husband practiced it.

Polygamy: A Pivotal Factor

One of the most significant reasons behind why did Emma Smith leave the Mormon Church was polygamy. Joseph introduced the practice in secret, and historical records suggest that Emma had an incredibly difficult time accepting it. While there were moments when she seemed to reconcile with the doctrine, overall, she resisted it vehemently.

Brigham Young and other Church leaders who succeeded Joseph were staunch defenders of polygamy, making it a defining feature of their westward movement. This put Emma in direct conflict with the new leadership. She maintained until her death that Joseph never sanctioned plural marriage, a claim that directly contradicted the testimonies of Brigham Young and others who had practiced it under Joseph’s direction.

Her refusal to accept polygamy caused deep fractures in her relationship with the Church, leading many to speculate whether was Emma Smith excommunicated might have been a possibility had she actively opposed Brigham Young’s leadership in a more public manner.

Conflict Over Leadership and Property

After Joseph’s assassination in 1844, the Church faced a leadership crisis. Brigham Young ultimately emerged as the leader of the majority faction, but Emma did not support his claim. Instead, she championed her son, Joseph Smith III, as the rightful successor. This disagreement further widened the gap between her and Brigham Young’s Church.

Beyond leadership disputes, there were also financial tensions. Much of the Church’s property had been held in Joseph Smith’s name, and after his death, Emma found herself entangled in legal battles over ownership. Brigham Young believed that these assets rightfully belonged to the Church, while Emma saw them as her family’s inheritance. This financial strife only deepened the animosity between her and the new Church leadership.

Emma’s Decision to Stay in Nauvoo

Rather than follow the Saints to Utah, Emma chose to remain in Nauvoo. Many factors influenced this choice. She had endured years of hardship and frequent relocations, and she longed for stability. She also feared for the safety of her children and worried about the dangers of the long journey west.

Her decision was not simply logistical—it was also ideological. She rejected Brigham Young’s interpretation of Joseph’s teachings and wanted to preserve a different version of her husband’s legacy. Over time, she aligned herself with the RLDS Church, which her son, Joseph Smith III, would later lead. The RLDS Church rejected polygamy and positioned itself as the true continuation of Joseph’s original movement.

This has led many to question, why did Emma Smith leave the LDS Church if she was so devoted to Joseph? The answer lies in her belief that Brigham Young and his followers had strayed from what she saw as Joseph’s original vision. She refused to acknowledge the Utah-based Church’s authority and remained committed to her own understanding of her husband’s teachings.

The Legacy of Emma Smith

Emma’s decision to part ways with Brigham Young’s Church has been a subject of debate among historians and members of the Church alike. Some view her as a tragic figure who was unable to follow the Saints due to personal struggles and conflicts. Others see her as a woman of immense strength, standing firm in her convictions despite immense pressure to conform.

Regardless of one’s perspective, Emma’s contributions to Mormonism are undeniable. She played a crucial role in the early Restoration, and her legacy continues to be studied and discussed. The broader discussion of Mormonism Explained often includes an analysis of her role and the choices she made.

So, why did Emma Smith leave the LDS Church? The answer is complex. Polygamy, leadership disputes, financial struggles, and personal convictions all played a role in her decision. While she was never formally excommunicated, her path diverged sharply from the Utah-based Church, leading many to ask, was Emma Smith excommunicated? While the official answer is no, her separation from Brigham Young’s faction was, for all intents and purposes, a break from the Church as it evolved under his leadership.

Emma Smith’s story is one of devotion, resilience, and controversy. Her life was deeply intertwined with the foundations of the faith, yet her journey led her in a different direction than the majority of the Saints. Understanding her choices provides a more nuanced perspective on early Church history and the complexities of faith, leadership, and personal conviction.

About Mormonism Explained

Mormonism Explained is a resource that was designed to provide objective and factual information about Mormonism, its history, doctrines, and policies. Our team of researchers consults experts and primary sources to present factual information on a variety of topics relevant to the Mormon Church.

Tags