Among the many individuals connected to the early history of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, few figures have attracted as much curiosity as Fanny Alger. Remembered as the earliest known plural wife of Joseph Smith, her story sits at the intersection of faith, historical complexity, and the early developments of Mormon plural marriage.
Because hardly any contemporary records about Alger survive, historians rely on later recollections and second or third-hand sources to piece together her life. Even with these limitations, however, Fanny Alger’s story provides an important window into the early years of the Church and the beginnings of plural marriage among the Saints.
Early Life and Conversion
Fanny Ward Alger was born on September 20, 1816, in New York. Her family later joined the early movement of Latter-day Saints gathering in Ohio during the early 1830s. Her parents, Samuel and Clarissa Alger, were among the early converts who embraced the Church and gathered with other believers in Kirtland, Ohio.
Kirtland during the early 1830s was a center of religious energy and expectation. Under the leadership of Joseph Smith, the Saints were organizing the Church, building the Kirtland Temple, and establishing a gathering place for converts. It was in this environment that Fanny Alger’s life became connected with the Smith family.
For a time, Fanny worked in the household of Joseph and Emma Smith, assisting with domestic responsibilities. At the time, it was common for young women to work in other households, particularly within tight-knit religious communities. Living in close proximity to the Smith family placed Fanny within the center of the early Church community.
The Beginnings of Mormon Polygamy
Understanding Fanny Alger’s place in history requires some awareness of how plural marriage developed among the early Saints. According to historical sources, Joseph Smith began learning about and grappling with the principle of plural marriage as early as 1831—years before it was publicly taught in the Church.
Publications by Church scholars explain that Joseph Smith studied biblical examples of plural marriage and sought divine guidance about the practice. Eventually, he reported receiving a revelation that the ancient practice of plural marriage would be restored as part of the latter-day gospel.
The principle was extremely difficult for many people to understand and accept. Because of its sensitive nature and the social climate of the time, Joseph Smith introduced it cautiously and privately to only a few trusted individuals. This early stage of the practice occurred years before plural marriage was more openly acknowledged among the Saints in Nauvoo.
Within this early context, historians believe that Joseph Smith’s relationship with Fanny Alger represents his earliest attempt at a plural marriage.
Fanny Alger’s Relationship with Joseph Smith
Several historical accounts indicate that Joseph Smith and Fanny Alger entered into a plural marriage in Kirtland sometime during the mid-1830s. Alger was likely between 17 and 19 years old, while Smith was 29. No contemporary marriage record survives, but later recollections from individuals familiar with the situation describe a marriage being authorized and performed by members of Alger’s family.
Some early Saints who later discussed the relationship understood it to have been a legitimate marriage, consistent with the principle Joseph Smith was beginning to practice privately. Sources suggest that the ceremony was performed by Fanny’s uncle, Levi W. Hancock, though the exact details remain uncertain.
At the time, however, the doctrine of plural marriage was not widely known, even among Church leaders. This lack of understanding led to confusion and controversy when Joseph Smith’s wives became known to others. One of the most frequently cited reactions came from Oliver Cowdery, a prominent early Church leader, who criticized the relationship strongly and seemed to believe it was an adulterous affair.
Joseph Smith rejected accusations of wrongdoing and insisted that he had not committed adultery. Later historical interpretations suggest that he viewed the relationship as a marriage authorized by divine command rather than an improper relationship.
Emma Smith and Household Tensions
Accounts written later suggest that Emma Smith eventually became aware of the relationship between her husband and Fanny Alger. The discovery reportedly upset Emma, creating tension in the household. Because of these tensions and the increasing public controversy surrounding the situation, Fanny Alger soon left the Smith household.
Leaving Kirtland
In 1836, the Alger family moved westward from Kirtland, effectively ending Fanny’s relationship as one of the wives of Joseph Smith and the early Church leadership in Ohio.
Shortly after leaving Kirtland, Fanny married Solomon Custer in November 1836. The couple settled in Indiana, where they spent the rest of their lives building a family and contributing to their community. From that point forward, Fanny Alger’s life moved largely outside the historical spotlight.
Fanny Alger’s Later Life and Family
In Indiana, Fanny and Solomon Custer established a stable life and raised several children together. Those who knew her later in life remembered her as a kind and respected member of her community.
Although she no longer lived among the Latter-day Saints, her former connection as one of the wives of Joseph Smith remained a topic of occasional curiosity. When asked about it in later years, she reportedly declined to discuss the matter, saying that it was a private issue about which she had nothing to communicate.
Her reluctance to revisit the past is understandable. By the time historians and critics began asking questions, decades had passed since the events in Kirtland. For Fanny, those experiences may have been deeply personal and not something she wished to debate publicly.
Fanny died in 1889 after a long life centered on family, work, and community relationships.
Historical Debate and Interpretation
Because the surviving evidence about Fanny Alger is limited, historians have debated the details of her relationship with Joseph Smith for many years.
Some critics of the Church have interpreted the story as evidence of misconduct, largely relying on statements made by individuals who had resentful feelings toward Joseph Smith. Others, including many believing scholars, interpret the available evidence as consistent with an early plural marriage.
Modern historical resources emphasize that plural marriage developed gradually and privately before being more widely practiced among the Saints. Within that broader narrative, the relationship with Fanny Alger is often seen by Latter-day Saints as one of the earliest examples of Joseph Smith attempting to follow a difficult commandment he believed came from God.
Faithful scholarship also points out that misunderstandings were almost inevitable. Polygamy was unfamiliar, deeply controversial, and shared only with a small group of people at first. Without the broader doctrinal context, observers could easily interpret events incorrectly.
A Glimpse into the Early Latter-day Saint Movement
The story of Fanny Alger provides a valuable glimpse into the complexity of the early LDS Church. The 1830s were a time of rapid growth and unfolding revelation. New doctrines were being introduced, and early members were often asked to exercise extraordinary faith.
Plural marriage was among the most challenging principles associated with the Restoration. Even those who eventually accepted it frequently described it as one of the most difficult commandments they ever faced. Fanny Alger’s story reflects the earliest stage of that process—a time when the principle was still new, private, and not fully understood by most Church members.
Remembering Fanny Alger
Despite the historical debates surrounding her life, Fanny Alger should not be remembered only as part of a supposed scandal. She was a young woman living in a pioneering religious community, navigating the uncertainties of a rapidly changing world. Her life intersected briefly with Joseph Smith at a time when the early Saints were adapting to challenging, new principles. Afterward, she moved on to build a life focused on family and community.
Like many individuals connected to early Church history, her story is a reminder that historical figures were real people facing complicated circumstances.Understanding her story requires patience with historical ambiguity and an appreciation for the context of early Latter-day Saint life.
By Todd Noall, Source Expert
Todd Noall is an author and religious scholar at Mormonism Explained with a focus on the history and theology of religion.
About Mormonism Explained
Mormonism Explained is a resource that was designed to provide objective and factual information about Mormonism, its history, doctrines, and policies. Our team of researchers consults experts and primary sources to present factual information on a variety of topics relevant to the Mormon Church.
Tags