Joseph Smith and Polygamy: A Deep Dive into the Practice and Its Spiritual Significance

The subject of Joseph Smith’s practice of plural marriage is one of the most controversial and misunderstood aspects of early Mormon history. The intricacies of this practice, its spiritual underpinnings, and its complexities have often led to confusion, both within and outside of the faith. It’s essential to approach this topic with an understanding of the historical context and the personal struggles Joseph Smith himself faced in the practice of plural marriage. To truly grasp the story, examining the Joseph Smith polygamy timeline is crucial.

The Complexities of Plural Marriage in Nauvoo

Joseph Smith’s practice of polygamy began quietly in Nauvoo during the early 1840s. Despite its somewhat private nature, the practice was not without complications, both from within and outside of the community. Three key figures in Joseph’s life played significant roles in the challenges surrounding this practice. The Joseph Smith polygamy timeline highlights these early years and the controversies surrounding this deeply personal and spiritual practice.

John C. Bennett was a prominent figure in the early history of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. A talented and charismatic individual, Bennett became an ally of Joseph Smith early on. However, he was later excommunicated from the church after it was discovered that he had secretly engaged in “spiritual wifery,” a practice that involved illicit serial adultery under the guise of religious sanction. Bennett’s public denunciations of Joseph’s practice of plural marriage became a significant source of public scandal and criticism. His actions, fueled by bitterness after his excommunication, worked to undermine Joseph Smith’s reputation and the practice of plural marriage. This aspect of the Joseph Smith polygamy timeline remains one of the most dramatic turns in the history of the movement.

Another person who played a pivotal role in complicating Joseph’s plural marriage practice was his brother Hyrum Smith, a member of the First Presidency. Although Hyrum was deeply committed to his brother Joseph, he struggled with the idea of plural marriage. For a time, Hyrum sought to curb the practice, even as he suspected that his brother and other leaders in the church were privately living plural marriages. However, his stance would dramatically change, leading to a significant shift in his view of plural marriage and its place within the Church. The Joseph Smith polygamy timeline shows how Hyrum’s eventual acceptance and support for the practice was critical in Joseph’s journey.

The third figure whose personal struggles with plural marriage were deeply intertwined with Joseph Smith’s experience was his wife, Emma Smith. Emma’s resistance to plural marriage was intense and long-lasting. Although she initially sought to understand and accept the practice, she faced significant emotional and spiritual struggles. Her opposition reached such a point that it nearly caused the breakdown of her marriage to Joseph. For Emma, the practice of plural marriage was not just a theological issue—it was deeply personal, affecting her sense of identity and her relationship with Joseph. The emotional toll on Emma is a key element in understanding the context of the Joseph Smith polygamy timeline.

A Reluctant Polygamist: Joseph Smith’s Own Struggles

Understanding Joseph Smith’s experience with plural marriage is crucial to understanding why he practiced it. Joseph’s journey toward embracing plural marriage was not a simple or eager one. Historical sources indicate that Joseph wrestled deeply with his feelings about the practice, as did many others. The Joseph Smith polygamy timeline reveals the years of internal conflict Joseph experienced as he came to terms with the doctrine.

In fact, Joseph himself admitted to his internal struggles regarding plural marriage. His wife, Lucy Walker, recalled that Joseph “had his doubts about it” and debated the practice in his own mind. Eliza R. Snow also recounted that Joseph was initially hesitant to teach or advocate for the practice of plural marriage, struggling against his natural inclinations and societal norms. It was not a decision he made lightly, nor was it something he felt comfortable with at first. In fact, it is often noted that Joseph feared the repercussions of teaching the doctrine and the impact it might have on both his family and his reputation.

Joseph’s reluctance to accept plural marriage continued for several years. In a striking series of accounts, it’s clear that Joseph had to be convinced to follow the divine command. According to some of his contemporaries, Joseph was visited by an angel on multiple occasions, who threatened him with severe consequences if he did not accept and establish the practice. Mary Elizabeth Rollins Lightner, a later leader in the church, reported that the angel came to Joseph with a drawn sword, warning him that if he didn’t proceed with the practice, he would be “destroyed.” This extreme intervention underscores the seriousness with which Joseph approached the matter. It is through these visits, noted in the Joseph Smith polygamy timeline, that Joseph was pushed to follow through with what would be a highly controversial, yet deeply spiritual, commandment.

Joseph’s own words on the subject, as reported by those closest to him, reveal the tremendous weight he felt in carrying out the practice. As Helen Mar Kimball Smith, one of Joseph’s wives, recounted, Joseph “would have shrunk from the undertaking” had it not been for the fear of divine displeasure. Ultimately, it was this deep fear and understanding of his responsibility to God that led Joseph to proceed with the practice of plural marriage.

The Role of the Scriptures and Divine Revelation

Joseph Smith’s understanding of plural marriage was rooted in divine revelation. According to Doctrine and Covenants Section 132, plural marriage was a commandment given by God. It wasn’t an arbitrary decision but rather a divine instruction, revealed to Joseph through his translation of the Bible and his studies of the Old Testament, particularly the stories of Abraham, Jacob, and other patriarchs who practiced plural marriage. As we explore the Joseph Smith polygamy timeline, it’s clear that this doctrine was intertwined with his larger understanding of scripture and divine authority.

The revelation on plural marriage, known as the “Revelation on Marriage,” was given to Joseph in 1843. However, it’s believed that the principles of plural marriage were known to Joseph as early as 1831, during his Bible translation work. Orson Pratt, quoting Lyman Johnson, noted that Joseph had discussed plural marriage as early as 1831, saying that the practice would one day be commanded by God. This early revelation indicates that Joseph’s eventual adoption of plural marriage was part of a broader divine plan, though it would take years for the practice to become publicly known and understood within the church.

Joseph’s decision to engage in plural marriage was also influenced by the spiritual needs of the time. It’s been suggested that plural marriage was intended to help establish a greater sense of celestial order and prepare individuals for eternal marriage and family structures. While some explanations have been offered regarding practical reasons for plural marriage, such as a disproportionate number of women in the early church or the necessity of ensuring righteous posterity, the central reason remains theological—a belief in divine commandments meant to structure the celestial kingdom.

The Concept of “Escaping Polygamy”

Many people continue to wrestle with the notion of Joseph Smith escaping polygamy tree in modern interpretations. Some view the practice as a temporary anomaly, while others consider it as a permanent part of Mormon doctrine. As the Joseph Smith polygamy timeline unfolds, it becomes evident that Joseph himself saw the practice not as a detour from God’s will but as an essential part of the eternal plan for families.

Conclusion

Joseph Smith’s practice of plural marriage remains one of the most complex and debated aspects of his life and teachings. His own personal struggles, the opposition he faced from within his family and the church, and the immense pressure to align with divine commandment are all crucial to understanding why Joseph practiced polygamy. To fully comprehend the circumstances and spiritual depth of Joseph’s actions, exploring the Joseph Smith polygamy timeline offers invaluable insight.

In light of this, it’s essential to approach the topic of Joseph Smith’s plural marriage with both respect for the complexities of the time and an understanding of the deeply spiritual convictions that guided him. His actions, while controversial, were seen by many as necessary for fulfilling God’s will in the establishment of His kingdom. By examining the historical record, including the voices of those who were involved in the practice, we can gain a clearer understanding of the trials and triumphs associated with Joseph Smith’s journey in establishing the doctrine of plural marriage. And for many, the question of did Joseph Smith have multiple wives remains central to the legacy and teachings that shaped the faith for generations to come.

About Mormonism Explained

Mormonism Explained is a resource that was designed to provide objective and factual information about Mormonism, its history, doctrines, and policies. Our team of researchers consults experts and primary sources to present factual information on a variety of topics relevant to the Mormon Church.

Tags